松辽盆地晚白垩世“海侵”事件争论及其解决建议Arguments and solutions on the transgression event in the Late Cretaceous of Songliao Basin
张顺
ZHANG Shun
摘要(Abstract):
松辽盆地北部已进入非常规页岩油勘探阶段,为了阐明坳陷层页岩形成的古环境特征,针对半个世纪以来松辽盆地晚白垩世"海侵"事件的争论,从古生物、地球化学及地质研究等10个方面进行了梳理和分析,指出有关"海侵"事件的争论主要存在赞成和否定2种观点。地球化学专家和学者主要是持赞成观点,他们甚至通过生物标志化合物与有机质丰度分布特征,推测出东部亚细亚海通过依—通地堑侵入松辽盆地的"海侵通道";古生物专家和学者主要是持否定观点,他们认为古生物化石以淡水和微咸水为主,少量的高盐度古生物化石并不具有"海侵"的唯一指向性。研究认为:争论焦点集中在水体咸化是湖泊盐度自然分层还是海水侵入所致,但存在3个方面的问题,一是古生态环境对比等时性问题,二是地质研究对古生态环境研究的约束性问题,三是不同领域研究的系统性与同步性问题;强调要充分利用丰富的连续取心井资料及盆地东部边缘完整的地质剖面,在5—6级高频层序地层格架内,同步进行系统的层序地层、沉积充填演化、古生物及地球化学方面分析,才能对坳陷层页岩是否属于"海侵"成因的问题得出可靠的认识。
At present, North Songliao Basin has entered the stage of unconventional shale oil exploration. In order to clarify the characteristics of formed paleoenvironment of depression-layer shale, focused on the debate of the transgression event in the Late Cretaceous of Songliao Basin for half a century, the detailed combing and in-depth analysis were carried out from 10 aspects such as paleo-biology, geochemistry and geology, and it was pointed out there are two main opinions in the debate on the transgression event, namely, yes and no. Most of geochemical experts and scholars agree with the positive view, and even infer that the East Asia Sea invades into Songliao Basin by means of Yi-Tong Graben-the transgression channel with the help of distribution characteristics of bio-marker compounds and organic matter abundance; while paleontologists and scholars mainly hold the negative view, believing that the paleontological fossils are mostly freshwater and brackish water, and a small amount of high-salinity paleontological fossils do not have the only directivity of transgression. The study shows that the focus of debate is whether the salinization of water body is caused by the natural stratification of lake salinity or seawater intrusion. Now, there are three aspects of the problem: first, the isochronism of paleoecological environment comparison; second, the constraint of geological research on the study of paleoecological environment; third, the systematization and synchronicity of research in different fields. It is emphasized that rich continuous coring well data and complete geological section on the eastern edge of the basin should be fully used, and the analyses on the sequence stratigraphic formation, sedimentary filling evolution, paleontology and geochemistry in the 5-6 high-frequency sequence stratigraphic framework should be systematically conducted so as to get a reliable understanding that whether depression-layer shale is the cause of the transgression or not.
关键词(KeyWords):
坳陷层页岩;海侵事件;晚白垩世;松辽盆地
depression-layer shale;transgression event;Late Cretaceous;Songliao Basin
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目“松辽盆地与辽西地区早白垩世古湖泊环境演化”(41790452)
作者(Author):
张顺
ZHANG Shun
DOI: 10.19597/j.issn.1000-3754.202004070
参考文献(References):
- [1]高瑞祺,何承全,乔秀云.松辽盆地白垩纪两次海侵的沟鞭藻类新属种[J].古生物学报,1992,31(1):17-29.GAO Ruiqi,HE Chengquan,QIAO xiuyun.New genus of Dinoflagellates in the Cretaceous two transgressions in the Songliao Basin [J].Journal of Palaeontology,1992,31(1):17-29.
- [2]侯读杰,黄清华,黄福堂,等.松辽盆地海侵地层的分子地球化学特征[J].石油学报,1999,20(2):30-34.HOU Dujie,HUANG Qinghua,HUANG Futang,et al.The characteristics of molecular geochemistry of marine transgression strata in Songliao Basin [J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,1999,20(2):30-34.
- [3]顾知微,于箐珊.松辽地区白垩纪双壳类化石[M].北京:科学出版社,1999.GU Zhiwei,YU Qingshan.Cretaceous bivalve fossils in Songliao area[M].Beijing:Science Press,1999.
- [4]陈瑞君.我国某些地区的海绿石特征及其对相环境分析的意义[J].地质科学,1980(1):65-75.CHEN Ruijun.Characteristics of glauconites from some regions and their significance in analyzing the facies environment[J].Scientia Geologica sinica,1980(1):65-75.
- [5]叶淑芬,魏魁生.松辽盆地白垩系的密集段及海水进侵的新证[J].地球科学——中国地质大学学报,1996,21(3):267-271.YE Shufen,WEI Kuisheng.Condensed section and new evidence of marine inundation in Cretaceous,Songliao Basin [J].Earth Science:Journal of China University of Geosciences,1996,21(3):267-271.
- [6]席党鹏,万晓樵,冯志强,等.松辽盆地晚白垩世有孔虫的发现:来自松科1井湖海沟通的证据[J].科学通报,2010,55(35):3433-3436.XI Dangpeng,WAN Xiaoqiao,FENG Zhiqiang,et al.Discovery of Late Cretaceous foraminifera in the Songliao Basin:Evidence from SK-1 and implications for identifying seawater incursions[J].Science Bulletin,2010,55(35):3433-3436.
- [7]万晓樵,吴怀春,席党鹏,等.中国东北地区白垩纪温室时期陆相生物群与气候环境演化[J].地学前缘,2017,24(1):18-31.WAN Xiaoqiao,WU Huaichun,XI Dangpeng,et al.Terrestrial biota and climate environment evolution during the Cretaceous greenhouse period in Northeast China [J].Earth Science Frontiers,2017,24(1):18-31.
- [8]冯子辉,方伟,张居和,等.松辽盆地烃源岩中高分子量(C+40)烷烃系列组成及分布特征[J].中国科学 D辑:地球科学,2007,37(9):1150-1162.FENG Zihui,FANG Wei,ZHANG Juhe,et al.Composition and distribution characteristics of high-molecular-weight (C+40) alkane series in source rocks of Songliao Basin[J].Science in China Series D:Earth Sciences,2007,37(9):1150-1162.
- [9]冯子辉,方伟,王雪,等.松辽盆地海侵制约油页岩形成的微体古生物和分子化石证据[J].中国科学 D辑:地球科学,2009,39(10):1375-1386.FENG Zihui,Fang Wei,WANG Xue,et al.Evidence from micro-paleontology and molecular fossils of oil shale formation controlled by transgression in the Songliao Basin [J].Science in China Series D:Earth Sciences,2009,39(10):1375-1386.
- [10]冯子辉,方伟,李振广,等.松辽盆地陆相大规模优质烃源岩沉积环境的地球化学标志[J].中国科学 D辑:地球科学,2011,41(9):1253-1267.FENG Zihui,FANG Wei,LI Zhenguang,et al.Geochemical signs of the sedimentary environment of large-scale continental high-quality source rocks in the Songliao Basin[J].Science in China Series D:Earth Sciences,2011,41 (9):1253-1267.
- [11]宁维坤,付丽,霍秋立.松辽盆地松科1井晚白垩世沉积时期古湖泊生产力[J].吉林大学学报(地球科学版),2010,40(5):1020-1026.NING Weikun,FU Li,HUO Qiuli.Productivity of Paleo-Songliao lake during the Late Cretaceous in Well Songke-1,Songliao Basin [J].Journal of Jilin University(Earth Science Edition),2010,40(5):1020-1026.
- [12]彭丽,伍轶鸣,练章贵,等.陆相断陷湖盆高频层序特征及其沉积演化:以渤海湾盆地济阳坳陷沙三下亚段为例[J].石油与天然气地质,2019,40(4):789-798.PENG Li,WU Yiming,LIAN Zhanggui,et al.Features and sedimentary evolution of high-frequency sequence in continental lacustrine rift basin:Example of the lower Shahejie member 3 in Jiyang Depression,Bohai Bay Basin [J].Oil & Gas Geology,2019,40(4):789-798.
- [13]王丽,宋之光.松辽盆地嫩江组脱羟基维生素E的分布及其地球化学意义[J].地球化学,2010,39(5):469-478.WANG Li,SONG Zhiguang.The distribution of methylated-2-methyltrimethyltride-cylchromans and geochemical implcation in Nenjiang Formation of the late Cretaceous from Songliao Basin [J].Geochemica,2010,39 (5):469-478.
- [14]黄第藩,李晋超.关于松辽和华北中、新生代沉积相的某些问题[J].地质论评,1982,28(3):217-227.HUANG Difan,LI Jinchao.Some problems about Mesozoic and Cenozoic sedimentary facies in Songliao and North China[J].Geological Commentary,1982,28 (3):217-227.
- [15]司伟民,席党鹏,黄清华,等.松辽盆地东部宾县凹陷青山口组介形类生物地层与生态环境[J].地质学报,2010,84(10):1389-1400.SI Weimin,XI Dangpeng,HUANG Qinghua,et al.Ostracode stratigraphy and palaeoenvironment of the Cretaceous Qingshankou Formation in East Songliao Basin[J].Acta Geologica Sinica,2010,84(10):1389-1400.
- [16]李杰,茅绍智,徐钰林,等.松辽盆地北部晚白垩世陆相沟鞭藻及疑源类特征与沉积环境研究[J].现代地质,2000,14(3):267-272.LI Jie,MAO Shaozhi,XU Yulin,et al.The Late Cretaceous nonmarine dinoflagellates,acritarchs and sedimentary environment in the northern Songliao Basin [J].Geoscience,2000,14(3):267-272.
- [17]邢顺洤,姜洪启.松辽盆地陆相砂岩储集层性质与成岩作用[M],哈尔滨:黑龙江科学出技术版社,1993.XING Shunwei,JIANG Hongqi.Properties and diagenesis of terrestrial sandstone reservoirs in Songliao Basin [M].Haerbin:Heilongjiang Science and Technology Press,1993.
- [18]万重芳,茅绍智.江汉盆地晚白垩世—早第三纪沟鞭藻、疑源类及其在沉积环境恢复中的意义[J].石油勘探与开发,1987,14(6):31-37.WAN Chongfang,MAO Caozhi.The Upper Cretaceous-Early Tertiary dinoly-flagellates and acritarchs of Jianghan Basin and their significance in reconstruction of depositional environments[J].Petroleum Exploration and Development Fat,1987,14 (6):31-37.
- [19]茅绍智,余静贤.陆相沟鞭藻的起源和演化及其生油意义[J].地球科学——中国地质大学学报,1990,15(3):283-290.MAO Shaozhi,YU Jingxian.Origin and evolution of terrestrial dinoflagellates and their significance in source potential for petroleum[J].Earth Science:Journal of China University of Geosciences,1990,15(3):283-290.
- [20]杨万里,高瑞祺,刘长瑞,等.松辽陆相盆地石油地质[M].北京:石油工业出版社,1985.YANG Wanli,GAO Ruiqi,LIU Changrui,et al.Songliao continental basin petroleum geology[M].Beijing:Petroleum Industry Press,1985.
- [21]顾健,黄永建,王成善.松辽盆地“松科1井”南孔青山口组泥岩岩相研究[J].中国矿业,2010,19(增刊1):161-165.GU Jian,HUANG Yongjian,WANG Chengshan.Mudstone lithofacies in the Cretaceous Qingshankou Formation from Drill Sk-Ⅰ,Songliao Basin[J].China Mining Magazine,2010,19(S1):161-165.
- [22]叶得泉,黄清华,张莹,等.松辽盆地白垩纪介形类生物地层学[M].北京:石油工业出版社,2002.YE Dequan,HAUNG Qinghua,ZHANG Ying,et al.Cretaceous biostratigraphy in Songliao Basin [M].Beijing:Petroleum Industry Press,2002.
- [23]李顺,席党鹏,荆夏,等.松辽盆地松科1井南孔晚白垩世介形类生物地层[J].古生物学报,2011,50(3):330-343.LI Shun,XI Dangpeng,JING Xia,et al.Upper cretaceous ostracod biostratigraphy of the CCSD-SK-Ⅰ(south)borehole,Songliao Basin[J].Acta Palaeontologica Sinica,2011,50(3):330-343.
- [24]黄清华,谭伟,杨会臣.松辽盆地白垩纪地层序列与年代地层[J].大庆石油地质与开发,1999,18(6):15-17.HUANG Qinghua,TAN Wei,YANG Huichen.Cretaceous stratigraphic sequence and chronostratigraphy in Songliao Basin[J].Petroleum Geology & Development in Daqing,1999,18 (6):15-17.
- [25]崔同翠.松辽盆地白垩纪叶肢介化石[M].北京:石油工业出版社,1987.CUI Tongcui.Cretaceous leaf limb fossils in Songliao Basin[M].Beijing:Petroleum Industry Press,1987.
- [26]张弥曼,周家健.我国东部中、新生代含油地层中的鱼化石及有关沉积环境的讨论[J].古脊椎动物与古人类,1978,16(4):229-237.ZHANG Miman,ZHOU Jiajian.On the fossils fishes in Mesozoic and Cenozoic oil-bearing strata from East China and their sedimentary environment[J].Vertebrata Palasiatica,1978,16(4):229-237.
- [27]黄福堂,迟元林,黄清华.松辽盆地中白垩世海侵事件质疑[J].石油勘探与开发,1999,26(3):104-107.HUANG Futang,CHI Yuanlin,HUANG Qinghua.Doubts about the validity of the Middle Cretaceous transgression in Songliao Basin[J].Petroleum Exploration and Development,1999,26(3):104-107.
- [28]朱毅秀,黄导武,王欢,等.东海西湖凹陷 A 气田渐新统花港组三段厚层砂岩沉积环境[J].石油与天然气地质,2019,40(6):1226-1235.ZHU Yixiu,HUANG Daowu,WANG Huan,et al.Sedimentary setting of thick sandstone in the 3rd member of the Oligocene Huagang Formation in A gas field in the Xihu Sag,East China Sea Basin[J].Oil & Gas Geology,2019,40(6):1226-1235.
- [29]余静贤,孙孟蓉,孙素英,等.广东三水盆地晚白垩世沟鞭藻和疑源类[J].石油与天然气地质,1981,2(3):225-263.YU Jingxian,SUN Mengrong,SUN Suying,et al.Dinoflagellates and acritarchs from Dalanshan formation and their significance in explain the depositional environment [J].Oil & Gas Geology,1981,2(3):225-263.
- [30]CANN J H,DE D P.Fossil Quaternary and living foraminifera from athalassic non-marine saline lakes,South Australia[J].Journal of Paleontology,1981,55:660-670.
- [31]WENNRICH V,MENG S,SCHMIEDL G.Foraminifers from Holocene sediments of two inland brackish lakes in central Germany[J].Journal of Foraminiferal Research,2007,37(4):318-326.
- [32]孙镇城,曾学鲁,陈克造,等.柴达木盆地盐湖有孔虫的发现及其地质意义[J].石油学报,1992,13(2):252-257.SUN Zhencheng,ZENG Xuelu,CHEN Kezao,et al.Discovery of foraminifera in the salt lake,Chaidamu Basin and its geological significance [J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,1992,13(2):252-257.
- [33]吴乃琴.弱海相性有孔虫群的特征及其代表的沉积环境[J].第四纪研究,1993,13(3):267-280.WU Naiqin.Characteristics of low-marineness foraminiferal faunas ln modern and Quaternary deposits and their geological implication [J].Quaternary Sciences,1993,13(3):267-280.
- [34]李元芳,李炳元,王国,等.青藏高原甜水海地区第四纪有孔虫化石[J].科学通报,1997,42(7):740-742.LI Yuanfang,LI Bingyuan,WANG Guo,et al.Quaternary foraminifer fossils in the Tianshuihai area of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau [J].Chinese Science Bulletin,1997,42(7):740-742.
- [35]肖应凯,肖军,赵志琦,等.延庆杨户庄第四纪有孔虫的非海相生存环境:硼和锶同位素证据[J].科学通报,2008,53(7):801-806.XIAO Yingkai,XIAO Jun,ZHAO Zhiqi,et al.Non-marine living environment of foraminifera of Quaternary in Yanghuzhuang,Yanqing:Evidence of boron and strontium isotopes[J].Chinese Science Bulletin,2008,53(7):801-806.
- [36]KAIHO K,FUJIWARA O,MOTOYAMA J.Mid-Cretaceous faunal turnover of intermediate-water benthic foraminifera in the northwestern Pacific Ocean margin[J].Marine Micropaleontolgy,1993,23:13-49.
- [37]NISHIA H,TAKASHIMAA R,HATSUGAI T.Planktonic foraminiferal zonation in the Cretaceous Yezo Group,Central Hokkaido,Japan[J].Journal Asian Earth Sciences,2003,21:867-886.
- [38] 郝诒纯,李蕙生.渤海沿岸及邻近地区早第三纪钙质超微化石的发现及其意义[J].科学通报,1984,29(12):741-745.HAO Yichun,LI Huisheng.Discovery and significance of early-Tertiary Calcareous ultrafossils along the Bohai Sea and adjacent areas [J].Chinese Science Bulletin,1984,29(12):741-745.
- [39]赵志清,吕红玉.东濮盆地晚始新世生物群及其古环境的探讨[J].微体古生物学报,1988,5(3):315-322.ZHAO Zhiqing,Lü Hongyu.Late Eocene biota in the Dongpu Basin and its paleoenvironment[J].Acta Micropalaeontologica Sinica,1988,5(3):315-322.
- [40]姚益民,徐金鲤,单怀广,等.山东济阳坳陷早第三纪海侵的讨论[J].石油学报,1992,13(2):29-34.YAO Yimin,XU Jinli,SHAN Huaiguang,et al.A discussion of the Paleogene transgression in the Jiyang Depression,Shandong province [J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,1992,13(2):29-34.
- [41]徐钰林,孙镇城.中国西北地区第四纪盐湖沉积中钙质超微化石的发现及其古环境意义[J].现代地质,1998,12(1):49-55.XU Yulin,SUN Zhencheng.Discovery of the Quaternary calcareous nannofossils in the deposits of interior saline lakes from northwestern China and its paleoenvironmental significance [J].Geoscience,1998,12(1):49-55.
- [42]孙镇城,冯晓杰,杨藩,等.中国西部晚第三纪—第四纪有孔虫和钙质超微化石的发现及其地质意义[J].现代地质,1997,11(3):269-274.SUN Zhencheng,FENG Xiaojie,YANG Fan,et al.Discovery of Neogene-Quaternary foraminifera and Calcareous nannofossils from western Chian and its geological significance[J].Geoscience,1997,11(3):269-274.
- [43]曹文心,席党鹏,黄清华,等.松辽盆地海侵事件:松科1井钙质超微化石新证据[J].地质通报,2016,35(6):866-871.CAO Wenxin,XI Dangpeng,HUANG Qinghua,et al.Seawater incursion event in Songliao Basin:New evidence from Calcareous nannofossils of SK-1 [J].Geological Bulletin of China,2016,35(6):866-871.
- [44]王云飞.抚仙湖现代湖泊沉积物中海绿石的发现及成因的初步研究[J].科学通报,1983,28(22):1388-1392.WANG Yunfei.Preliminary study on the discovery and formation of sea chlorite in the sediments of modern lakes in Fuxian Lake[J].Science Bulletin,1983,28(22):1388-1392.
- [45]PETERS K E,WALTERS C C,MOLDOWAN J M.The biomarker guide:Biomarkers and isotopes in petroleum systems and earth history[M]London:Cambridge University Press,2005.
- [46]王铁冠.论分子有机地球化学若干名词与术语的辨析和厘定[J].地质论评,2002,48(3):284-288.WANG Tieguan.Discrimination and stipulation of some terms of molecular organic geoehemistry [J].Geological Review,2002,48 (3):284-288.
- [47]张立平,黄第藩,廖志勤.伽马蜡烷—水体分层的地球化学标志[J].沉积学报,1999,17(1):136-140.ZHANG Liping,HUANG Difan,LIAO Zhiqin.Gammacerane geochemical indicator of water column stratification [J].Acta Sedimentologica Sinica,1999,17(1):136-140.
- [48]黄思静,吴素娟,孙治雷,等.中新生代海水锶同位素演化和古海洋事件[J].地学前缘,2005,12(2):133-141.HUANG Sijing,WU Sujuan,SUN Zhilei,et al.Seawater strontium isotopes and Paleo-oceanic events over the past 260 Ma [J].Earth Science Frontiers,2005,12(2):133-141.
- [49]金明玉,张顺,付秀丽,等.松辽盆地萨尔图地区嫩江组二段滑塌扇的发现及其石油地质意义[J].石油天然气学报(江汉石油学院学报),2010,32(5):187-190.JIN Mingyu,ZHANG Shun,FU Xiuli,et al.Discovery of sliding fan of the second member of Nenjiang Formation in Saertu area of Songliao Basin and its petroleum geological significance [J].Journal of Oil and Gas Technology(J.JPI),2010,32(5):187-190.
- [50]梅啸寒,刘景彦,王武学,等.扶新隆起带泉头组层序地层格架及发育模式[J].断块油气田,2019,26(4):415-420.MEI Xiaohan,LIU Jingyan,WANG Wuxue,et al.Sequence stratigraphic framework and development model of Quantou Formation in Fuxin Uplift in Songliao Basin[J].Fault-Block Oil & Gas Field,2019,26(4):415-420.
- [51]李军辉,李跃,张赫航,等.海拉尔盆地贝尔凹陷南屯组扇三角洲沉积特征及模式[J].大庆石油地质与开发,2019,38(3):8-17.LI Junhui,LI Yue,ZHANG Hehang,et al.Sedimentary characteristics and model for the fan delta in Nantun Formation of Beier Sag in Hailar Basin[J].Petroleum Geology & Oilfield Development in Daqing,2019,38(3):8-17.
- [52]白静,徐兴友,陈珊,等.松辽盆地长岭凹陷乾安地区青山口组一段沉积相特征与古环境恢复:以吉页油1井为例[J].中国地质,2020,47(1):220-235.BAI Jing,XU Xingyou,CHEN Shan,et al.Sedimentary characteristics and paleo-environment restoration of the first member of Qingshankou Formation in Qian’an area,Changling sag,Songliao Basin:A case study of Jiyeyou 1 Well[J].Geology in China,2020,47(1):220-235.
- [53]刘硕,高有峰,尹永康,等.松辽盆地大陆科学钻探“松科2井”登娄库组二段沉积序列精细刻画及时代归属[J].世界地质,2019,38(4):1032-1043.LIU Shuo,GAO Youfeng,YIN Yongkang,et al.Fine description and geological age delineation of sedimentary sequences of the second member of Denglouku Formation based on ICDP scientific drilling borehole in Songliao Basin ( SK2)[J].Geology in China,2019,38(4):1032-1043.
- [54]童晓宁,胡建芳,祝孟博,等.松辽盆地姚家车站剖面嫩江组一段下部湖相有机质组成及其沉积环境特征[J].地球化学,2019,48(2):149-160.TONG Xiaoning,HU Jianfang,ZHU Mengbo,et al.Paleoenvironmental changes during the deposition of the lower Member 1 of the Nenjiang Formation in the Songliao Basin,Northeastern China[J].Geochimica,2019,48(2):149-160.